Transfer pricing: Is your company ready for Zimra’s seven-day demand?

Simbarashe Hamudi

Simbarashe Hamudi

IN Zimbabwe, transfer pricing refers to the prices and terms set for trans­actions between related or connected parties, such as a local company and its parent, a sister company or an overseas affiliate. Under section 98B as read with 35th schedule of the Income Tax Act, those prices must reflect what indepen­dent parties would have agreed in com­parable circumstances, known as the arm’s-length principle.

Management fees paid to a parent, rent charged by a sister company, interest on a shareholder loan and goods sold to a foreign affiliate may all look routine in a set of accounts. Yet each raises the same question: would unrelated parties have agreed to the same terms?

For Zimbabwean companies with controlled transactions, the answer lies in transfer pricing documentation. This is the evidence that explains the commer­cial arrangements, the pricing methods and the comparisons used to show that related-party dealings meet the arm’s-length principle. Alongside section 98B, the legal framework includes the 35th Schedule and the supporting documenta­tion regulations.

The distinction that matters is be­tween transfer pricing and mispricing. Transactions within a group are a normal part of doing business. The tax exposure arises when the prices attached to them cannot be supported. Statutory Instru­ment 109 of 2019 requires taxpayers to keep contemporaneous documentation showing that their controlled transac­tions are consistent with the arm’s-length principle. Documentation counts as con­temporaneous if it exists by the filing date of the tax return. Once the Commis­sioner makes a written request, it must be produced within seven days.

That timeline leaves no room for a last-minute scramble. Documentation is not something to commission only after an audit notice lands on the finance di­rector’s desk. The sensible approach is to gather evidence throughout the year, review pricing before filing, and resolve inconsistencies while the people respon­sible are still available to explain them. Many local businesses assume transfer pricing only matters when money leaves the country. That assumption is wrong. ZIMRA’s ITF 12C2 return expressly covers both international and domestic related-party transactions.

Shared premises, intercompany loans, consultancy arrangements and costs allocated between local subsid­iaries all fall within scope. A property company and an operating company under common ownership, for exam­ple, should be able to explain their rental arrangement clearly: what space is occu­pied, what services are included and how the rent was set.

A useful transfer pricing document tells the company’s commercial story accurately. The regulations require in­formation on business operations, group structure, controlled transactions, meth­od selection and comparability analysis, together with relevant economic infor­mation and a conclusion on whether the transactions satisfy the arm’s length principle. That is far more than attaching a group organisation chart to a pricing policy. Management must explain who performs the work, which company owns the relevant assets and how respon­sibilities are divided. The analysis should reflect the Zimbabwean entity’s own circumstances, not simply reproduce a foreign parent’s report without testing whether it applies locally.

Management and technical fees re­main a key review area. The questions are straightforward: were the services ac­tually received, did they duplicate work already done locally, and do the charges include costs that properly belong to the shareholder? These questions should shape record-keeping. If a parent com­pany charges for information technology support, the subsidiary should keep ser­vice requests, reports, correspondence and cost calculations. If costs are allocat­ed by headcount or usage, management should be able to explain why that mea­sure fairly reflects the service provided. An invoice marked “management ser­vices” should be the start of the explana­tion, not the whole of it.

Shareholder loans, guarantees and intercompany balances deserve equal attention. Companies should record why funding was needed, how repayment was expected and how the contractual terms were chosen. Balances described as temporary advances that remain out­standing indefinitely are a warning sign. A written treasury policy should set out who approves funding and who reviews the terms. Agreements, accounting en­tries and actual conduct must tell the same story. When circumstances change, the arrangement should be revisited rath­er than left running on an outdated de­scription simply because it appeared in the original contract.

Unsupported benchmarking, miss­ing sources and methods copied from earlier reports are common weakness­es. A company should be able to ex­plain its comparisons: where the data came from, why it was selected and which differences might affect the re­sult. A standard markup applied across a group is not self-justifying. Businesses should challenge the assumptions behind their analysis and keep the calculations that support it. Where reliable compara­bles are scarce, that limitation should be acknowledged openly rather than hidden behind a conclusion that only appears precise.

ZIMRA’s published practice notes set out penalties on tax shortfalls arising from transfer pricing adjustments: 100% where fraud or evasion is involved, 30% where compliant contemporaneous doc­umentation is absent, and 10% where such documentation exists and meets the requirements. Documentation does not guarantee that ZIMRA will accept a company’s pricing. But the gap between a 30% and a 10% penalty shows plain­ly why compliant preparation pays. The focus should be on the quality of the ev­idence, not on whether a report with the right title has been bought.

The ITF 12C2 asks whether doc­umentation exists, what proportion of international transactions it covers and which transactions lack it. Those dis­closures make consistency between the report and the return essential. Mis­matched figures, inconsistent currencies and documents prepared after filing all undermine a company’s position. Trans­action schedules should be reconciled with financial statements, ledgers and counterparty records before submission. Differences should be investigated and explained, not rolled forward into the next reporting period.

Transfer pricing documentation be­longs in the mainstream of responsible business management. Directors should assign clear ownership of the process, re­view significant arrangements and make sure supporting evidence remains ac­cessible. The strongest document is not necessarily the longest. It is the one that accurately links commercial decisions, contractual terms, actual conduct and fi­nancial results.

For Zimbabwean companies with re­lated-party dealings, the message is clear, preparation must begin before scrutiny arrives. The goal is not simply to have a report on the shelf, but to have a defen­sible explanation ready when ZIMRA comes asking.

l Hamudi is a Managing Partner at Baker Zimbabwe, based in Harare, Zimbabwe. He can be contacted at +263 775 399 536 or simbarashe.ha­mudi@bakertilly.co.zw

Related posts

The playground has changed

Zimbabwe’s hospitality property goldmine

AI and the new burden of corporate governance

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Read More