Bothwell P. Nyajeka
THE quality of board oversight depends not only on the information directors receive, but also on their willingness and ability to ask the right questions. Indeed, silence in the boardroom can be costly.
A company has two engines, the board and management. They must be properly aligned and work towards a common purpose, creating sustainable value for shareholders while safeguarding the interests of other stakeholders.
Management runs the company from the operational trenches, making day-to-day operational decisions. The board, on the other hand, operates from the boardroom, providing strategic direction, monitoring performance, overseeing management and ensuring robust corporate governance. Crucially, this separation of responsibilities does not absolve directors of accountability.
Directors often ask me why they are held accountable for what happens in a company when they are so far removed from its daily operations. My answer is: directors do not need to run the company to understand what is happening in it. They must receive reports from management and ask the right questions. That is precisely where effective board oversight begins.
In my experience, the vital link between management and the directors is the board pack. This is an information package prepared by management and circulated to directors ahead of a board meeting, ideally at least seven days before. Boards should ordinarily meet at least quarterly, and more frequently when circumstances demand.
The pack should give directors a clear and balanced picture of the company’s affairs, detailing financial and operational performance together with strategic progress and risk matters. Most importantly, management must be truthful and candid when they prepare the pack. Directors need to see the good, the bad and the ugly.
Furthermore, the pack must be presented in a format agreed upon with the board. A board pack is not a marketing tool designed to impress directors. It is a governance instrument designed to inform them.
This distinction is critical as directors face intensifying pressure to demonstrate proper oversight. Whenever a company collapses, suffers a major financial scandal or experiences a serious governance failure, the public, regulators, and shareholders inevitably ask: where was the board?
To answer that question, a director’s most potent tool is the ability to ask incisive questions after thoroughly scrutinising the pack. A director need not be an expert in everything, but must be sufficiently informed, curious and courageous to ask management to explain matters that are unclear, inconsistent or potentially threatening to the company’s future.
Unfortunately, boardroom silence remains a persistent liability. Some directors fear asking what they consider stupid questions, or a desire to avoid appearing to embarrass or confrontational to management. Others find themselves intimidated by dominant personalities or worry about being labelled troublemakers. But silence comes at a price. In my view, a director who consistently fails to ask questions, particularly when there are obvious warning signs, does a disservice to the shareholders who appointed him/her and to the company to which he/she owes fiduciary duties.
Drawing on my experience in corporate governance and boardroom practice, I have developed several strategies and practices that can help directors break this silence and ask management the right questions.
First, there is no substitute for thorough preparation. Directors must dedicate sufficient time to scrutinise the board pack before the meeting, going beyond the executive summary to understand the underlying financial and operational information. Today, artificial intelligence (AI) tools can serve as a powerful ally in synthesising these dense materials, provided confidential company information is handled with care and in accordance with the company’s AI policy.
Understand the room. Every boardroom has its own culture and personalities. An effective director understands these dynamics and builds constructive relationships with fellow directors and management. Mutual trust makes difficult questions easier to ask.
Mind your manners. How a question is posed can matter as much as the question itself. A director who always challenges management aggressively puts executives on the defensive, making useful information harder to obtain. The purpose of questioning is to inform and improve decisions, not to humiliate management.
Stay sceptical, not distrustful. Directors should not accept every explanation at face value, but this does not mean distrusting management. It means maintaining a healthy professional scepticism and understanding the reasoning behind each proposal. One diagnostic question I find particularly useful is: “What are we not seeing, or what could we be overlooking?”
Seek independent help. Directors are not expected to know everything. They should never hesitate to consult the external auditors, legal advisors or other independent professionals. Relying on specialised, external expertise is not a sign of weakness, it is a hallmark of diligent governance.
Hold your ground. There will be times when a director genuinely disagrees with management or fellow directors. That is part of boardroom life. A director’s primary duty is to act in the best interests of the company, not to please management, the chairperson or other influential individuals.
Know the boundary line. Probing questions must never cross into day-to-day operations. The board’s mandate is to provide direction, oversight and strategic guidance; management’s mandate is to execute.
Engage beyond the meeting. Boardroom engagement does not begin and end at the meeting. Directors should use appropriate opportunities to interact with fellow directors, senior executives and professional advisers outside formal sessions. One of the practices most companies are using are the annual board retreats where management and the board have an opportunity to interact outside the boardroom. Such contacts create trust and give a platform to discuss issues that deserve closer attention and were not raised in the boardroom.
Listen and follow up. Asking questions is not an end in itself. Directors must listen carefully to the answers, judge whether the explanations are satisfactory and ensure that matters requiring action are followed up.
The ultimate test of a board is not how smoothly its meetings run or how quickly resolutions are passed. Rather, it is whether its collective deliberations empower the company to make sharper strategic decisions, mitigate risks, create sustainable value and remain a going concern.
l Nyajeka is a business turnaround, corporate strategy and governance consultant. He is also a seasoned facilitator with the Institute of Directors, Zimbabwe and chairman of ACR Solutions. For business turnaround, corporate strategy development and board advisory services contact him on bnyajeka@acr4solutions.com